Straight men-do you prevfer a butt plug or a finger in your ass?

I know that i can't really comment on this because i'm not a dude lol but i think it's INCREDIBLY HOT that guys actually like to get fingered or like having a butt plug in them. it's such a turn on

I personaly love to have a buttplug up my ass. It realy turns me on when my girlfriend orders and tells me I have to wear the buttplug out in public with her such as movies, dinner, playing pool or when she makes me wear it wear it to bed and keep it in all nigh til morning. Sometimes she wants to I wear the buttplug all day at work, and to make sure I don't take it out while at work she makes me wear a locking buttplug harness. When we are with her friends she says, tell my friends what your wearing honey, and I have to tell them or she threatens to tell my guy friends that I wear a buttplug. Very humilating. So now I actualy have become accustom to having to wear the plug.

My guy likes both (a small plug though) and my small fingers.

None of the men I have been with have shown any interest in that, and only a couple have wanted anal sex. Many think it's gross.

I have had both and can say without doubt that I prefer the finger in my ass. A womans finger can move around and stimulate me better despite the smaller size. Also, if you want more size, she can shove two fingers inside rather than just one.

Both =P while masturbating I sometimes use a butt plug and my girlfriend usually fingers me during Oral sex.

Some do, many think it is taboo. honestly if they ever tried it they would want it all the time.

either works for me! a real cock is fun too!

Fingers are great but unless you can find the prostate and gently rub it back and fore; then a generous sized vibrating butt plug is better. I'm straight but I've love having my butt played with.

Love the butt plug, I have 6 all different sizes and do wear some of them out in public. The real big ones though I can only wear for about a couple hrs. so I just walk around the house naked with them in me.I have had many orgasms with them in and also my wife pulling it out just as I cum, both are intense orgasms.

I prefer a butt plug to a finger, it is a much fuller experience, even better is a inflatable one.

actually my wife makes me to wear a butt plug..she thinks its very nice because that makes me being hard all the time...we are practising many years now with anal sex..receving and giving...i personaly wear a plug many hours during day..and she loves it.
thank you

Both are great for me. I like the fingers because they are easy to lube up, slide in and out, and control. The butt plug is a much fuller feeling, doesn't move when in, and takes a lot of work. I suppose it would depend on the mood. If it is spontaneous, a finger will do. For lengthy pleasure, a butt plug for sure.

Butt plug mostly. It depends on my wifes finger nails. internal cuts aren't that fun.

Oh lordy....when a woman fingers and tickles my ass I go straight out the world and will automatically pound into her as hard as I can....uncontrollable pleasure...

butt plug. Im straight as they come but I really like anal pleasure. a fingure is to small, a dildo is nice if its about 2"-3" thick and about 9"-18" long but a butt plug is the best. an inflatable butt plug is even better.

i myself have only experienced a finger n i had a long time to be convinced to try it the first time wasnt to pleasurable but thenext time was insane just women if u ever wanna try this with ur man dont pull a big toy on him for the first try its a turn off if it spooks him so just a finger then aafter awhile excelerate to the toys just a tip

finger - never had butt plug

I prefer a plug over fingers mostly because I have a problem dealing with the sight or smell of fecal matter so having it on my partners finger is a huge turn off

I definitely love the gulp of a plug as it slides in. but I'll take a good fisting before the plug (or incorporated together as my fave

Finger. I don't enjoy anything inanimate to be inserted.

actually either... have only tried my own finger, so would be interested in the plug as well

Both, but I love the idea of my woman making me wear a butt plug... especially if we go out in public. It has always been one of my sexual fantasies.

I like small dildos or butt plugs myself. My wifes nails are a killer period. And the first time she used her finger during oral it was a feeling that I wanted more of.

I don't like it in, I prefer a massage of the area between my anus and testicles. That would do basically a similar thing in terms of real stimuli.

The anus itself is very sensitive and a wet tongue or lubed finger massaging that is also great.

Just no penetration.

I've never tried the ol' butt plug before, so I suppose I lean towards the finger.

Emma why not comment on how you and your female companions like different things in your ass, I bet that would be interesting to hear, maybe a video?

What for? Personally i don't like things up my ass, what do you find more suitable of fun?

Neither.

I'm a 42 yr old virgin i wear womens thong panties, and only thongs would love a woman to fuck my ass till i couldnt sit down or walk for a day.

i would like finger and butt plug...with the blug i feel more full...but in the time of sex i would like to be penatreted by a finger

Definitely butt plug! Much smoother, and larger/longer in size! The portability is a huge plus too, being able to wear it in public gets me very aroused :) You should use a double dong with him, that would be my ultimate fantasy cuz you get your cheeks slapping each other ala Requiem for a dream! Hot!!

MMMMMM I just wat to get stuffed fingers, but plugs, dildos, vibrators or a nice cock. I am now just getting my girlfriend to start playing with my ass. I love the feel and sensation of having tings inserted in my ass

Neither. The only things that come near my butthole are soap and my boxers, period!

i like a good vib plug.

i like a girl finger in my ass

i love to finger... just finger

I've had both up the rear and can appreciate either. Plugs are convenient in public when you can't receive the manual stimulation provided by hand power. While I'm not gay, I have also had a penis inserted in me while bound to a bed and gagged. I prefer the real thing over an inanimate object.

My wife has always been very good at using her fingers to massage my prostate. But lately she has begun using a dildos after the finger massage. She has been increasing the size gradually and now she is using one that is 7 1/2 inches around and 10 inches long.

When I cum the first time, it is intense, and she can usually get me off again in just a few minutes.

Share your answer...

I have used butt plugs for a lot of years but only recently I do it more often. I have one in now and it feels great. The wife knows nothing about it and would be shocked but she's not into sex anymore so I get it wherever I can. I haven't worn it out it public but will.
I like a finger or a dildo but the plug is more of a long term pleasure tool.

I love fingering my ass hole so much. I have only tried the finger, but I will buy a butt plug. I'm working on getting my asshole wider. it's so damn delicious to finger in the asshole

Share your answer...

you are all sick, sick fuk-ups are you sure your mum and dad aint cousins

sometimes in the mood for finger , sometimes the fullness of a huge buttplug

Use a medium size pyrex glass buttplug during intercourse. It slips up into place so nicely. It really intensifies the feeling just before ejaculation. I guess that would be the orgasm, wouldn't it! Alone I like a P-Spot vibrator, and for a special treat, a Zeus torpedo, e-stimulator! It has an automatic 15 minute pulse pack with levels of intensity, including a vibrator if you like. Still trying to get the Aneros Progasm to work. That's the latest new toy! It will take the straight man to new levels, once you get past the stigma of this type of thing being gay. I came from the era when, as an adolescent as early as five, having orgasms from having my temperature taken rectally at the Doctor's office. It was embarrassing, even after ejaculating, being rolled over and still having a throbbing erection. There was no vanity at that time. You were completely naked in front of everyone! I didn't even know what was happening at the time, but realized it as I got older. I guess that's where it all began. All guys will feel it sooner or later, as they get their first prostate exam. My Doctor don't like the "bend over" method. He likes you on your back, or side with legs up when he inserts his finger in to the knuckle and does a complete 360 with it.

I love fingering my ass hole so much. I have only tried the finger, but I will buy a butt plug. I'm working on getting my asshole wider. it's so damn delicious to finger in the asshole

I actually enjoy both, a finger provides a great prostate massage. I also like an anal plug and the fact that I am harnessed into it, disallowing my removal of it until I am released from it my my love is quite sensual. I have been in public wearing the plug and like an earlier responder, was made to admit that I was plugged. Much to my surprise, another male friend of mine was forced to admit that he was at that very time in a chastity device (CB 2000). Upon that bit of news (and the fact that were were all going out to the pool) it was very apparent that I was plugged and he was chastised. Our wives all thought this was most humerous, our humiliation even more grand. They then conspired to make this a more often event, with us both being plugged and chastised. A later pool date did find my friend and I both plugged chastised but also later on bound to the beach chairs and the gagged for the next few hours. Along with that, we were both placed in open-toe heels and then had numerous pictures taken to ensure that we would "behave" down the road.

LOVE both! but of these two choices, i prefer a butt plug.

My wife loves seeing me receive anal of any sort. butt plug... fingers... dildos... however, her favorite is doing me with a strap-on =P

fingers, strap-ons.....It's all good!