Koran
 
Question:
Avatar

Is music is un-Islamic? as suggested in Hadith Qudsi 19:5: "The Prophet said that Allah commanded him to destroy all the musical instruments, idols, crosses and all the trappings of ignorance."

By sharpjwe Asked Oct 24 2009 1:51AM
9
Pts
 
 
Rate Question
Answer Question Help someone!
Get the latest questions in Koran
flag

Welcome to Answerbag, a community of people sharing what they know.
Sign up now to ask a question or help someone else by giving an answer!

signup now
Sort answers by: Rating | DateArrow Down
 

Top Answer out of 2

by Anonymous on Oct 24, 2009 at 1:58 am Permalink

Avatar
I'm not an Islamic scholar, but my personal take on that verse is that Muhammad,pbuh,was commanded to destroy instruments that had been used in the religious ceremonies of the polytheists. Not a prohibition on instruments or music in general. +5
11
Pts
 
 
Rate Answer
 
flag
Comments show all comments Show More
Avatar Anonymous Oct, 24 2009 at 07:18 PM
Not only pray, but pray their way. There's a Christian Taliban in the US right now that would do the same thing if they could get away with it.
Avatar Anonymous Oct, 24 2009 at 07:21 PM
From Bangkok? Are the Reds and Yellows still in the streets? Was there about 6 months ago, military advisory mission.
Avatar sharpjwe Oct, 24 2009 at 08:13 PM
well reds are out yellos in
thay start the democracy

Answer 2 out of 2

by Excalibur on Oct 24, 2009 at 2:08 am Permalink

Avatar
Well you know what religious followers are like, they choose the verses that suit them and disgard the rest. I don't think there is one single muslim wedding in the world that does not have music and, we must not forget bellydancers.... And of course there is the classical, bedouin, and folkloric music. However, it is true that the pursuit of the arts (except for the rich legacy of poetry in the Arab world which dates from before Mohammed) was certainly discouraged. What is sad is that, at the beginning of the Ummayad period there were images painted on the interior of mosques (ref. Bernard Lewis). It would have been interesting to see what the islamic world would have looked like if art (painting) had been allowed to flourish as much as poetry was.
1
Pts
 
 
Rate Answer
 
flag
Comments show all comments Show More
Avatar plocrates Oct, 27 2009 at 02:30 AM
In a crime ring leaders always hold biggest responsibility, look at the pack of cards Iraq, saddam. some people just follow for there own survival,
Avatar sharpjwe Oct, 27 2009 at 09:50 AM
i agree the leaders are guilty
the folowers are vicitims
religions are guilty to spread hate and lies
Avatar plocrates Oct, 27 2009 at 01:33 PM
: )


Add an Answer

Is music is un-Islamic? as suggested in Hadith Qudsi 19:5: "The Prophet said that Allah commanded him to destroy all the musical instruments, idols, crosses and all the trappings of ignorance."

How to write a good answer
Your answer:

Display answer in fixed-width font (good for tables or text diagrams)

Answers must adhere to our Terms of Use

To create links, just type the address with no HTML code. Use the Preview button at the bottom to verify.

You can edit your answer at any time.

Add Video Add Iimage


Important: Answerbag cannot guarantee the accuracy of answers submitted by members, and we recommend that you use common sense when following any advice found here. Read full disclaimer.