ANSWERS: 55
-
Billy is good, but Elton is better.
-
Billy Joel. Can't stand the other one
-
If I had to choose, Elton.
-
Billy Joel, I like music rather than pantomime and tantrums.
-
Ooh, that's a toughie. I'm gonna go with Elton John.
-
I like Billy Joel more but Elton may have better music. I like Joels' voice more.
-
Billy Joel.
-
Elton John!!!!!!!
-
Billy Joel is annoying in concert and he has very few good songs. Elton John is much more accomplished.
-
Billy Joel
-
Elton John
-
I love Elton John
-
Too close to call.
-
elton john if i must
-
old regie would win
-
I liked both, but not any more. EJ before 1976. BJ before 1984. I don't listen to Elton now. I still listen to about 6 old Billy Joel albums at least once a year.
-
billy joel cos we didnt start the fire
-
Elton is a better musician and songwriter. His songs are way better than Billy's. He plays non=stop in concert where Billy talks too much inbetween and it's all bull!! I met them both and found Billy to be a jerk!!!
-
Billy Joel is a legend. I never cared for Elton John. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bXTcws6vNGc
-
billy joels makes better songs but elton does good colabarations e.g. ghetto gospel so ad have to say they are even
-
Can't decide....I have to take both.
-
Elton without a doubt.
-
Elton John - no contest - without a shadow of doubt!!
-
Elton John!!! LOVE him.
-
ELTON!!!!!!!
-
Billy Joel. His songs are actually catchy and easy to remember because they're so good. John's lyricist is perhaps the worst ever. Anyone who makes Neil Diamond lyrics look pretty good, he's pretty bad! And the music is inoffensive and all, but not hardly worth taking home.
-
billy joel hands down
-
Slight edge to Elton.
-
Definatly Elton!!! I would LOVE to see him in concert..he was just here a few days ago....wish i had the money
-
billy joel for me
-
Billy Joel...........
-
sir elton because we go waaaay back
-
Elton John. No questions asked.
-
Billy Joel, but they're both about the same.
-
Blooming heck, this is a hard one! Erm... I think I'd side with Elton for consistency, but Piano Man is the best song either of them have
-
Elton John
-
Dang... Billy Joel!
-
While both are very talented, they both also have a high annoyance factor for me. I'll take Billy Joel.
-
Billy Joel
-
Elton John.
-
Billy Joel!
-
....
-
Elton John
-
Elton John.
-
Elton John but Billy Joel is a good one too. +5
-
Do like Elton's music
-
Elton John
-
elton
-
Billy Joel
-
Elton John!!
-
That's difficult, because i like them both. It's gonna have to be Elton.
-
thats a tough one - they are both good, but I have to say Elton
-
Elton John.
-
both equal to me. Elton a tad bit more. both great.
-
Tough, but Elton John.
Copyright 2023, Wired Ivy, LLC