What do you think of using shock collars to train a dog in the case of aggression towards other dogs?
by 
Sweet Baby Jane
ANSWERS: 16
-
I don't think that it will really stop the problem...it will just merely 'mask' the real issue. It may be effective in some cases, but I don't think it's a permanent fix. I don't particularly like shock collars anyway and I don't think that they are really an effective training tool.
-
I have to slightly disagree with my friend Cindimh. Shock collars can be a very effective tool for training a dog. If used correctly. But deffinitely not to be used all the time. Some of the most respected trainers will use shock collars. It's all down to preference. Do I use one on my dog? No I don't. I prefer alternative methods for training a dog. In your case, I would suggest filling a tin half full with stones and sealing it. When your out with your dog and it begins to show signs of agreesion, shake the tin hard right next to it's ear and shout "NO" It will distract your dog long enough for you to get your dog away from the other dog. You need to get the timing right. Watch your dog when another approaches then take action. If you keep repeating this you will find the dog is less likely to be aggressive towards other dogs. Eventualy a "no" will suffice. I would also reccomend if you haven't, taking your dog to doggy social classes. So it can get used to other dogs. If all else fails seek a profesional trainer. Good luck.
-
I once thought that shock collars were entirely monstrous and cruel -- until I fostered a dog who was an amazing escape artist. The only way she could be kept off the fence was by the use of a shock collar. I tried it on myself first to make sure that it was set to just a low weird tickling sensation. She hated that, and it worked. But even after that positive experience, I feel that shock collars are very easy to abuse, even accidentally (such as not realizing the power has been turned up). I like the noisy can full of stones idea better. Professional trainers are terribly expensive... but so are lawsuits from dog fights. :(
-
I agree with Cyndimh...it only masks the problem. I had a situation with my two female dobermans fighting for dominance and someone suggested the use of shock collars to get them to stop. However, I couldnt bear to do it to them so I ended up having to find one of them another home. I'm sure each situation is unique and I dont believe they "harm" the animal it just wasnt for me.
-
I personally disagree with shock collars.
-
I thonk shock collars are cruel. I believe a better alternative is a muzzle-leash combo that snaps the dogs mouth shut when you pull on the leash.
-
Not for aggression, but I've seen them as a last resort usually for something that you need the dog to be free, off leash for. And it only works with some breeds of dogs and with lots of professional training, not some person doing it themselves. They are to easy to abuse.
-
Check out Cesar Milan's book and/or videos (The Dog Whisperer)...he does not advocate shock collars...but behaviour modification by the pack leader - YOU.
-
I think if you are dealing with dog aggression with your dog, you really need to get a dog trainer involved, even if it's just for some advice. The fact is aggression toward other dogs can turn to people. This is really serious especially with some breeds. We as people have to learn and understand how to to use choke, pinch ( plastic is best ) collars even vibrating or low level shock To be treating aggression over and over with shocking will make the dog MORE aggressive and can be dangerous for you. Check out neutering, talk with your vet about hormone shots, talk with a trainer, neuter, and the first action should be obediance classes so that the dog is more socialized. Good Luck
-
We used a shock collar on our dog, and it did not have the correct effect. The poor dog was shocked at times that had nothing to do with the behavior we wanted to change. We took it off after a few very tearful (on my part)hours. It was horrible.
-
The only thing coming to mind is to watch and read Ceaser Milans' show and books. I think you can find many helpful hints in his program/books. He is a trained dog whisperer, and is very good at what he does. He can make a dog calmer like you wouldn't believe. It takes patience to settle down a disruptive/abusive dog. He finds ways where you don't have to go to those kinds of extreme measures to better the disposition of your dog. Check out his tv show, and books. I think you will be surprised 8o)
-
Shock collar wont stop agression in this case,establishing pack leader ship will....how many dog will you meet on the street when you walk your dog..there is no way you can shock the dog each time you see one..besides this technique is use only by proffesionals,mostly for training dogs for police,army and some protection dogs..because these are highly agrresive dogs with strong drives... Also if you use it on your dog too often,you create dog that will be frighten of dogs later,because in his mind thats what delivers the pain each time he see one....and trust me thats not what you want...you have to make your dog submit a front of other balanced dog,dont do it with other agressive or dominant dog you will end up separating a dog fight....
-
I would put those collars on certain people i dont like !
-
Pretty good sign of someone who does not know how to train a dog - they should be banned, both the collar and the trainer {?} -keep the dog.
-
Contrary to popular opinion in this thread, I am here to attest to their effectiveness. We have no dog, but my wife purchased one anyway. I now ALWAYS put the seat down!!!! :-)
-
I use a shock collar but as a last resort for when he ignores a command and would otherwise (i) get lost or (ii)put himself i danger. They are not recomended for use to counter aggression because they tend to fuel the aggression rather than snapping the dog out of it and generally make the situation worse.
Sunset RELATED QUESTIONS
Copyright 2023, Wired Ivy, LLC