It is "Turn Out the Stars" by the Manhattans. http://www.amazon.com/Even-Now-Manhattans/dp/B00005RDEP/ref=m_art_li_17/105-7081434-4084410

1) "Turn Out the Stars," by The Manhattans...? (these two songs r pretty sad ...but they HOT, ya'll - they HOT!) this one goes... "So pull the moon down from the sky... I won't need no more light... If you through with these arms, Lock the door to my heart, And walk away with the key... And turn out the stars When you leave." Source: http://forums.hbcuconnect.com/music/952-what-chall-know-about-these.html 2) "you say were through it over between me and you. the fire has gone out, it's time we both find someone new. ooooo.oh, how it hurts to hear you say those words. cause there never be another someone for me on this earth. chours: So pull the moon down from the sky, I won't need no moon light. If your through with these arms lock the door to my heart. and walk away with the key and turn out the stars when you leave. oooh. you always be the one i'll aways need and If It's over for sure I'll just love your memory. Chours:chours: So pull the moon down from the sky, i won't need no moon light.Girl If your through with these arms lock the door to my heart. and walk away with the key and turn out the stars when you leave. i'll never love anyone else(i'll never) so if you say goodbye you just might as welllll, oh Chours: So pull the moon down from the sky, I won't need no moon light. Girl If your through with these arms lock the door to my heart. and walk away with the key and turn out the stars when you leave. ooooo! I won't need no moon light! girl If your through with these arms lock the door to my heart. and walk away walk away with the key and turn out the stars when you leave.(turn out the stars) Saxaphone plays. Girl if your through with my heart right here is where we'll have to part! Turn out the light baby. Turn out the stars when you walk out the door and leave me girl!" Source: http://de.oleo.tv/mail.html?id=240062

My God!!!Thank you all so so much! I have been trying to remember those lyrics and couldn't. The radio station couldnt figure it out cause I have a terrible singing voice and only knew that one line! Oh, you guys are a life saver!!