Do you think castration should be mandatory for repeat violent sex offenders?
Or do you think this is a violation of basic civil rights?
by 
ANSWERS: 6
-
Society continually tries to rehabilitate for some reason. That people can learn new behaviors. I believe child molesters have forever lost ability to be around children as I do not want to take a change that they are not rehabilitated .
-
-
Linda Joy Are you saying yes or no to castration? -
Black Mystique Guess I'm saying no....but maybe we could give them something like a bracelet that goes off when they are within 50ft of whatever they are restricted from. -
Archie Bunker What good is a bracelet alarm going to do someone who is being raped?? -
Black Mystique Good point. What about a pill that kills any desire??
-
Linda Joy That's what chemical castration is for.
-
Black Mystique Ok, maybe yes on Chemical Castration then
-
Archie Bunker I vehemently disagree. A child molester has no redeeming value to me. They should be in prison for life or killed. There is no justification for victimizing a child.
-
D Green Well, I don't think they should be given a second chance myself, yes I think you are right Archie
-
-
Rapist and child molesters should be castrated or killed.
-
Yes, because violent sex offenders shouldn't have any civil rights.
-
-
Linda Joy
You just contradicted yourself. Actually prisoners are not afforded the same rights we are. They surrender most of them when they choose to commit a crime.
-
-
Then what would you do to female sex offenders or castrated sex offenders? Although the punishment fits the crime, I don't know that it truly solves it. Violence is something on a whole different level. Those who are violent won't necessarily continue their violence, but they are much more likely to do so, because their potential barrier to commit violence is erased. Since the sort of violence up for discussion here is a particularly awful kind, people with a history of such violence, compounded with the unpleasant and violent punishment doled out to them, psychologically, are more apt to continue with another form of violence.
-
-
Linda Joy
"Surgical castration reportedly produces definitive results, even in repeat pedophilic offenders, by reducing recidivism rates to 2% to 5% compared with expected rates of 50%. Chemical castration using LHRH agonists reduces circulating testosterone to very low levels, and also results in very low levels of recidivism despite the strong psychological factors that contribute to sexual offending" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3565125/#:~:text=Surgical%20castration%20reportedly%20produces%20definitive,with%20expected%20rates%20of%2050%25. -
Linda Joy
I found this interesting: " We also found that males were much more likely to self-report being victimized by female sex offenders compared with females (40% vs. 4%)." -
bostjan the adequate 🥉
How do they even know what percentage of crimes are reported versus not?! And if it's not reported, but they still know when it happens, why don't they do something about it?!
-
-
Yes any person whether Male or Female and commits a rape or sexual assault of any kind should be castrated
-
Not only do I think it should be mandatory, I'd like the job of actually doing it. It would be more interesting than working on a food packing factory.
Glambarber 
DancesWithWolves 
Flipflopgal RELATED QUESTIONS
Copyright 2023, Wired Ivy, LLC