by thatsJustme on April 27th, 2008

thatsJustme

Question

Help answer this question below.

Is Muhhamed's claim to be a descendant of Abraham through son Ishamael able to be traced , lineage? what is KNOWN of Muhammed....?and if he could not write, who did? just asking..

  • Like
  • Report

Answers. 8 helpful answers below.

  • by singwell-is off researching a lot on May 6th, 2008

    singwell-is off researching a lot

    The general belief of genealogists (who are the experts in this field, and have taken many many descents back as far as they can go) is this:
    Ancestry of the Prophet Muhammad
    The Prophet Muhammad's ancestry is traced back to Adnan around 100 BC. This is probably myth.
    Beyond that, this attempt to link Adnan to the Biblical Abraham is obvious mythology. Apart from anything else, even if Abraham existed, he would have lived something like 2300 BC.

    http://humphrysfamilytree.com/Islam/index.html
    The amount of written literature around in the ARabian peninsula at the time of Muhammad was negligible (one of the major reasons why the Quran is held by Muslims to be so special- it comes from a time when the Arabs had not a lot of written material), so, at best you would only have a verbal genealogy. That is not to say that verbal genealogies cannot be accurate- on the contrary, many of the Welsh and Irish oral genealogies from a similar period are held to be accurate for many generations before they descend into political statements (everyone goes back to Noah, or Adam or to a prominent person in history).

    The descent below for Mohammad from Adam is in this vein. It may be accurate for a number of generations, and, like all human genealogies, will end up at Adam, but proof for the descent is lacking, and there are clearly many generations missing)


    Muhammad's pure descent from Adam
    Sirat p. 3
    Muhammad was the son of Abdallah, b. Abdul-Muttalib, b. Hisham, b. Abdu Manaf, b. Qusayy, b. Kilab, b. Murra, b. Kab, b. Luayy, b. Ghalib, b. Fihr, b. Malik, b. al-Nadr, b. Kinana, b. Khuzayma, b. Mudrika, b. Ilyas, b. Mudar, b. Nizar, b. Maadd, b. Adnan, b. Udd, b. Muqawwam, b. Hanur, b. Tayrah, b. Yarub, b. Yashjub, b. Nabit, b. Ismail, b. Ibrahim, b. Tarih, b. Nahur, b. Sarugh, b. Rau, b. Falikh, b. Aybar, b. Shalikh, b. Arfakhshadh, b. Sam, b. Nuh, b. Lamk, b. Mattushalakh, b. Akhnukh (prophet Idris?), b. Yard, b. Mahlil, b. Qaynan, b. Yanish, b. Shith, b. Adam.

    Note that this descent does not go through Abraham, however.

    The Quran does not list a genealogy of Muhammad to show how he is descended from Abraham, although it more than implies that the Arabs are descended from Abraham through Ishmael. This seems to have been something that came from the teachings of Muhammad alone, as it seems not to have been an Arabic belief before his time. I found this on one site:


    According to at least one Muslim writer, in pre-Islamic times Ishmael was never mentioned as the father of the Arabs. In his rebuttal to Dr. Robert A. Morey's book Islamic Invasion, W. Aliyyuddin Shareef, is honest enough to admit:

    "In pre-Islamic times Ishmael was never mentioned as the Father of the Arabs." (Shareef, In response to Robert Morey's Islamic Invasion, pp.3-4)

    Is Muhammad's belief that the Arabs are descendants of Abraham justified? they are definitely Semites by language and culture, but is there proof of descent from Ishmael?
    No.
    The same site records:
    There is also debate over whether Ishmael ever migrated to Mecca, seeing that the Holy Bible clearly denies that Ishmael ever settled in Arabia. The Holy Bible states that Ishmael and his mother settled in Paran near southern Palestine in northeastern Sinai. The proof that Paran is located in the region of Sinai, and not in Mecca, comes from the Holy Bible:

    "And the children of Israel took their journeys out of the wilderness of Sinai; and the cloud (of God) rested in the wilderness of Paran." Numbers 10:12

    "And afterward the people (Israelites) removed from Hazeroth, and pitched in the wilderness of Paran." Numbers 12:16

    "And Moses by the commandment of the Lord sent them from the wilderness of Paran... And they went and came to Moses, and to Aaron, and to all the congregation of the children of Israel, unto the wilderness of Paran, to Kadesh..." Numbers 13:3, 26

    "These be the words which Moses spake unto all Israel on this side of Jordan in the wilderness, in the plain over against the Red sea, between Paran, and Tophel, and Laban, and Hazeroth, and Dizahab." Deuteronomy 1:1

    The preceding verses clearly demonstrate that Paran could not possibly be Mecca but a locale near Sinai, since Moses and the Israelites never settled in that part of Arabia.
    =========
    If Ishmael was never in Mecca, but around the Sinai peninsula, then....
    Moreover, we can know for sure that Abraham was never in Mecca because his story is recorded accurately in the Old Testament, up to 1000 years before the Quran existed, and his journey can be traced by the mention of the wells and other sites within the Old Testament text. He came from Mesopotamia, settled in Canaan (modern Israel) and there he stayed (with a small excursion along known trade routes, to Egypt, and back again). He died and was buried in Machpelah in Israel, alongside his wife, Sara, and his heir, Isaac. Isaac's heir, Jacob is also buried in the same tomb.Muslims know this because they have built a mosque over the top of the tomb (to stop the Jews from being able to worship at their ancestor's grave).
    Had Abraham gone with Ishmael to Mecca (which is right off the known trade routes from Israel anyway. It might seem close on a map, but trade routes were fixed and followed wells. There were no wells through the almost impenatrable Arabian desert to Mecca), why, then, would he have buried his wife in Israel, and then returned (as an extremely old man) to be buried beside Sara by Isaac, who then joined his parents in the grave when his time came.
    Where is Ishmael's burial place? No where to be found. WHen he was made to leave with his mother, the slave girl Hagar, they went and did not return. Ishmael was no doubt loved by his father and was not abandoned by God, but Ishmael was not the heir. (see Genesis 17: "As for Sarai your wife, you are no longer to call her Sarai; her name will be Sarah. I will bless her and will surely give you a son by her. I will bless her so that she will be the mother of nations; kings of peoples will come from her." Abraham fell facedown; he laughed and said to himself, "W ill a son be born to a man a hundred years old? Will Sarah bear a child at the age of ninety?" And Abraham said to God, "If only Ishmael might live under your blessing!" Then God said, "YES, BUT YOUR WIFE SARAH WILL BEAR YOU A SON, AND YOU WILL CALL HIM ISAAC. I WILL ESTABLISH MY COVENANT WITH HIM AS AN EVERLASTING COVENANT FOR HIS DESCENDANTS AFTER HIM. And as for Ishmael, I have heard you: I will surely bless him; I will make him fruitful and will greatly increase his numbers. He will be the father of twelve rulers, and I will make him into a great nation. BUT MY COVENANT I WILL ESTABLISH WITH ISAAC, WHOM SARAH WILL BEAR TO YOU BY THIS TIME NEXT YEAR." When he had finished speaking with Abraham, God went up from him. Genesis 17:1-22 )
    The heir, Isaac, was buried beside the father.
    =============
    What is known of Muhammad? Outside of what information is given in the Quran, nothing. No outside references from the time refer to him. We can deduce his approximate birth year c 570 AD, in Mecca, from the Quran and the Hadith, and we can know his death date, June 8, 632 Medina.
    We know who he married, and what his life was like from the Quran and the Hadith narratives.

    He did not know how to write, that is true, but that has never been a great problem. Many famous leaders in the past did not know how to read or write, or were not good at it. They employed emanuenses (writers) to do the work.

    The various Sura (or revelations) of Muhammad were recorded by various writers who were close to him, and eventually collected into one volume, after his death. This became important in the time of Caliph Uthman, who heard that variant readings of some of the suras were causing disputes, and also,because after the wars of apostasy and the Battle of Yamamah in particular a large number of those who had committed the Quran to memory perished. .

    He asked Zayd ibn Thabit, who had known Muhammad personally,had been one of Muhammad's emanuenses, and was well versed in the suras, to put together an official version of the Quran, based on his memory of what was correct. All variant manuscripts were then burnt, much to the horror of their holders.

    • Like
    • Report

    9 comments | Post one | Permalink

  • by Piso on May 6th, 2008

    Piso

    I cant find historical evidence of abraham adam or eve, so sorry i cant answer it

    • Like
    • Report

    1 comment | Post one | Permalink

  • by JESUS-IS-MUSLIM on February 18th, 2009

    JESUS-IS-MUSLIM

    According to the Jewish Encyclopedia, about KEDAR:
    http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=156&letter=K&search=kedar

    Kedar:
    "One of the sons of Ishmael (Gen. xxv. 13; I Chron. i. 29). The name is also applied in Scripture to the tribe that sprang from him, and is likewise used for the Bedouins generally, whose characteristic traits are ascribed to Kedar (Cant. i. 5; Isa. xxi. 16, xlii. 11, lx. 7; Jer. ii. 10, xlix. 28; Ezek. xxvii. 21). While very little is known of Kedar, the head of the tribe, his posterity, called also the "Bene Kedar" (Isa. xxi. 17), are described as barbarous tribes in connection with Mesech. "Woe is me," says the Psalmist (Ps. cxx. 5), "that I sojourn in Mesech, that I dwell in the tents of Kedar!" According to other passages, they appear to have been rich in flocks of sheep and goats, in which they traded with the Syrians (Ezek. xxvii. 21; Jer. xlix. 49). They dwelt in tents of black hair (Cant. i. 5) in the midst of the wilderness of Arabia, and were known as skilful archers (Isa. xxi. 17). But they also settled in villages or towns (Isa. xlii. 11). According to Mohammedan tradition, Kedar ("Ḳaidhar" ) was the ancestor of Mohammed; and it is through him that Mohammed's descent is traced to Ishmael (Caussin de Perceval, "Essai," i. 175).E. G"

    • Like
    • Report

    No comments. Post one | Permalink

  • by Cs01kh on May 6th, 2008

    Cs01kh

    I'll try to get back to you on this (though I am not the best person to answer this). Just a question, what do you mean when you ask "What is KNOWN of Muhammed"? do you mean his reputation? Accepted history? known of him before he became a prophet or after he became a prophet? etc... can you clarify that part of the question?

    • Like
    • Report

    7 comments | Post one | Permalink

  • by bob_chasm on October 8th, 2010

    bob_chasm

    singwell says,

    "Note that this descent does not go through Abraham, however." Then presents us with this lineage:

    Muhammad was the son of Abdallah, b. Abdul-Muttalib, b. Hisham, b. Abdu Manaf, b. Qusayy, b. Kilab, b. Murra, b. Kab, b. Luayy, b. Ghalib, b. Fihr, b. Malik, b. al-Nadr, b. Kinana, b. Khuzayma, b. Mudrika, b. Ilyas, b. Mudar, b. Nizar, b. Maadd, b. Adnan, b. Udd, b. Muqawwam, b. Hanur, b. Tayrah, b. Yarub, b. Yashjub, b. Nabit, b. Ismail, b. Ibrahim, b. Tarih, b. Nahur, b. Sarugh, b. Rau, b. Falikh, b. Aybar, b. Shalikh, b. Arfakhshadh, b. Sam, b. Nuh, b. Lamk, b. Mattushalakh, b. Akhnukh (prophet Idris?), b. Yard, b. Mahlil, b. Qaynan, b. Yanish, b. Shith, b. Adam.

    My response: Anyone can see that the above lineage clearly states Muhammad was a descendant of Ismail b. Ibrahim b Tarih.

    (Ismail is Arabic for Ishmael, Ibrahim is Arabic for Abraham and Tarih is Arabic for Terah. So clearly Muslim traditions record Muhammad as a descendant of Abraham.)

    Next singwell says,

    "According to at least one Muslim writer, in pre-Islamic times Ishmael was never mentioned as the father of the Arabs. In his rebuttal to Dr. Robert A. Morey's book Islamic Invasion, W. Aliyyuddin Shareef, is honest enough to admit:

    "In pre-Islamic times Ishmael was never mentioned as the Father of the Arabs." (Shareef, In response to Robert Morey's Islamic Invasion, pp.3-4)

    Is Muhammad's belief that the Arabs are descendants of Abraham justified? they are definitely Semites by language and culture, but is there proof of descent from Ishmael? No. ..."

    My response: So who is right Allah and Muhammad or the Arabs and the western historians? Let us examine the evidence and see who knew the truth?

    Here is what the Quran says:


    And strive hard in Allah's Cause as you ought to strive . He has chosen you, and has not laid upon you in religion any hardship, it is the religion of your father Ibrahim (Abraham). It is He (Allah) Who has named you Muslims both before and in this (the Qur'an), that the Messenger (Muhammad SAW) may be a witness over you and you be witnesses over mankind! So perform As-Salat (prayer), give Zakat (Alms) and hold fast to Allah. He is your Maula (Patron, Lord, etc.), what an Excellent Maula (Patron, Lord, etc.) and what an Excellent Helper! S. 22:78

    Here is what modern science has discovered:



    46.1% of Cohanim carry Y chromosomes belonging to a single paternal lineage (J-P58*) that likely originated in the Near East well before the dispersal of Jewish groups in the Diaspora. Support for a Near Eastern origin of this lineage comes from its high frequency in our sample of Bedouins, Yemenis (67%), and Jordanians (55%) and its precipitous drop in frequency as one moves away from Saudi Arabia and the Near East (Fig. 4). Moreover, there is a striking contrast between the relatively high frequency of J-58* in Jewish populations (»20%) and Cohanim (»46%) and its vanishingly low frequency in our sample of non- Jewish populations that hosted Jewish diaspora communities outside of the Near East.[12]

    So clearly 46% of Jews share a more recent common ancestor with Saudis, Yemeni (67%) and Jordanians (55%), than any other people in the world, such as Europeans, Africans and Indians etc. The question becomes how recently do the 46% of Jews share a common ancestor with the Arabs? Recent studies suggest less than 5,000 years ago. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haplogroup_J1c3_(Y-DNA)

    Notice, there are just Arabs and Jews by the time we get down to less than 5,000 years with Jews at the J1c3d level:

    http://www.familytreedna.com/public/j1el147/default.aspx?section=yresults

    The obvious Jewish names are 142, 143, 144, 145, 147, 152, 158, 164, 165, 174, 187 among others. Almost all the other are Arabs.

    Hence, if there is a people who could be considered Ishmaelite who shared a recent common male ancestor with the Jews, it would have to be the Arabs and no other. My question is, how did Muhammad know if the Arabs and modern historians didnt know?

    No comments. Post one | Permalink

  • by Anonymous on October 29th, 2008

    Anonymous

    no there is no direct lineage mentioned in the Quran. muhammad himself admitted he knew his ancestors only upto 17 generations & anyone adding more names to the list of ancestors was lying... muhammad could not write & one of the people who wrote his genealogy was Ibn Ishaq

    No comments. Post one | Permalink

  • by midas81 on April 11th, 2010

    midas81

    It should not be important because Muhammad was just a man who allegedly was chosen to do some work and create Islam.

    No comments. Post one | Permalink

  • by thatsJustme on February 18th, 2009

    thatsJustme

    Ishmael was not of the 12 Tribes in the the Covenant Promise of Abraham and Sarah..the Savior came down through Judah, the only Jews of the tribes..the only tribe that lasted till Jesus was born, HE was a Jew of Judah...as Prophecy said...
    Hagars child was not in the Covenant Promise, only Sarah's....Sarah lost FAITH in God when she grew impatient with HIM(took 10 yrs. before God sent she and Abraham the Promised son, Isaac)and told Abraham to take Hagar...I guess Abraham's faith wavered too or he would have said no..but even so, God kept the Promise with Abraham and Sarah, and Jacob too...this had to be to bring the Savior in ..through Judah..
    we are all descendants of Abraham through Noah and his 3 sons, Shem, Ham and Japeth....Noah, Shem, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Judah,Perez,Esrom,Aram, Naasom, Salmon,Boaz, Obed,Jesse, King David,on to Mary and Joseph who were both of Davidic line..Joseph by adoption and Mary by blood ..the seed of woman.Genesis 3..

    No comments. Post one | Permalink

Want to attach an image to your answer? Click here.

Did this answer your question? If not, then ask a new question or create a poll.

You're reading Is Muhhamed's claim to be a descendant of Abraham through son Ishamael able to be traced , lineage? what is KNOWN of Muhammed....?and if he could not write, who did? just asking..

Follow us on Facebook!

Related Ads

ANSWERBAG BUZZ

Muhammad s descent from adam
Descents of ishmael
Direct descendants of muhammed
Descendents of muhammed