I enjoy them. I think they were extremely overhyped at their peak of popularity in early 2006 or so (as were Sufjan Stevens, Of Montreal, Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, Arctic Monkeys, and all the other indie-darlings-of-the-day), but not necessarily overrated.

They have more universal appeal than most of those, though. I still prefer metal, prog, or hip-hop over indie generally, but hey, keep on keepin' on. It's much better than Creed.