Answer to The Australian philosopher Colin Leslie Dean has argued that Godels incompleteness theorem is invalid. Do you believe that his argument is valid?

Thu, 26 Feb 2009 01:48:24 -0800

The Australian philosopher Colin Leslie Dean has argued that Godels incompleteness theorem is invalid. Do you believe that his argument is valid?

Why should anyone care what a philosopher thinks about a problem in mathematics? Would you give any weight to a mathematician's opinion about a new technique in brain surgery?

Answerbag: Dillard's answers

Answer to The Australian philosopher Colin Leslie Dean has argued that Godels incompleteness theorem is invalid. Do you believe that his argument is valid?