- NEW!
This question's purpose is to show that morality is subjective and influenced by cultural values.
Short answer: I think the ethical choice would be the middle-aged woman.
A University teacher presented this question to the class, and she explained how the answers tend to change based on cultural values, so when you answer, can you say which one you voted on, your reasoning, and the culture(s) you grew up in.
She said Americans would generally pick the baby, since it is young and has not experienced life yet like the other two. But the Chinese would pick the old woman, since she is honored for being elderly and wise with experience.
I don't agree with either. I think the elderly woman has lived most her life and is more likely to be prepared for death. The baby is new to life, pure of heart, and does not fear death, not to mention if some of your beliefs are correct, it is guaranteed to go to Heaven, which would be a good thing, wouldn't it? The middle-aged woman is more likely to have a lot more people that need her than the other two. Much more likely to have a husband and/or kids she's raising, and more likely to have a job. She has built up a lot, and has a lot more planned ahead of her. Plus she's least likely to be prepared for death, unlike the old woman. So in my opinion, which seems to be disagreed with by most, is the middle-aged woman should be saved. I think that is one moral way to look at it.
by Troy_W5542
on November 15th, 2011
voted:
Middle-aged woman
by Snatchsquach
on November 15th, 2011
voted:
None
by R.I.P Daddy :,( In loving memory❤
on November 15th, 2011
voted:
Middle-aged woman
by KDP
on November 15th, 2011
voted:
baby
by trouble... staying calm on November 15th, 2011
What makes a good husband&father?
by Answerbag Staff on May 4th, 2010
| 2 people like this
How do we (collectively) determine what's right and what's wrong, while being fair to everyone??
by PrimeFactor on May 1st, 2012
| 1 person likes this
"At Least they Are Straight" (See Below)?
by mdGreg on May 5th, 2012
| 1 person likes this
If you could only save the love of your life (future or current) or one thousand people from death, which would you save?
by ~*Araya*~ on May 2nd, 2012
| 2 people like this
Agree or disagree - It is wrong of theists and atheists to advertise and publicise or preach their beliefs/ disbeliefs?
by anil m on May 1st, 2012
| 1 person likes this
You're reading If an elderly woman, a middle-aged woman, and a baby were on a boat that was sinking, and you can only save one, which would it be and why?
Your favorite Q&A site is on Facebook! Become a fan to connect with the ever-growing community of Answerbaggers, share your thoughts and find out what Answerbag's up to next!
Comments