Who do you think is better, John Lennon or Paul McCartney?

Comments

• I agree :-)

  • Report
  

  by Bornabrit on December 27th, 2011

Comments

Comments

Comments

• He was a terrible father and had a anger problem, His first son he literally abandoned and also said that he'd realized he had more photos of Paul with him then his own father John.
  
  His second son had hearing damage because of John Lennon. Do your research, John was a talented but a total cunt.

  • Report
  

  by Awesome on September 14th, 2011

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

• Oh I agree!

  • Report
  

  by Over and Out on December 27th, 2011

Comments

• You're an idiot, You said John Lennon WAS The Beatles. THen named a song that wasn't even made during the beatles.
  
  Look up all the greatest songs by The Beatles and you'll realize they were made by Paul.

  • Report
  

  by Awesome on August 8th, 2011

• You're an idiot too.....look at both of the songs I listed and they were both recorded AFTER The Beatles..the question is NOT about The Beatles,it's about Lennon & McCartney...oh look,Lennons name is first....always credited that way,and more than likley for a reason.
  
  It's subjective,and to one's own personal taste....best Beatles tunes for me are:
  
  Tomorrow Never Knows -- A Lennon song
  Something - A Harrison Song
  
  And maybe they did want to do McCartney / Lennon for James's songs,but it never happened...James being McCartney's real first name,named after his father.

  • Report
  

  by kidder1 on August 8th, 2011

• Yesterday, Let it Be, For No One, I'm Looking Through You, Michelle, Eleanor Rigby, The long and winding road and they are just some of the beatle songs McCartney wrote. And you're an idiot for saying The Frog Chorus, SINCE IT WAS MADE FOR A CHILDREN'S FILM.

  • Report
  

  by Awesome on August 8th, 2011

• Not disputing the songs he wrote,I merely listed my 2 favorites of which McCartney wrote neither.A childrens ANIMATED film called Rupert and the Frog Song to be precise.And you are one angry,bitter individual for calling someone an idiot,that you don't know,for expressing an opinion that does not conform to your own.If you don't like it,move on elsewhere....jog on.

  • Report
  

  by kidder1 on August 8th, 2011

• "John Lennon WAS The Beatles."
  
  An arrogant comment and most likley offensive to fans of George Harrison's guitar playing and song-writing, Also offensive to drummers who look upto Ringo's drumming and fans of Paul's song-writing, singing and bass guitar playing.
  
  "Lennon wrote Imagine,McCartney wrote The Frog Chorus...end of !"
  
  You obviously implied something there, And it should be clear why I would be offended.
  
  Don't forget you counter-attacked previously with "You're an idiot too....." Which also makes you an angry individual for childishly attacking with the same insult. I would've accepted your opinion like many of the others and had a proper discussion if you had made it obvious it was only your opinion instead of coming up with a statement comparing to pieces of work from Paul and Lennon as a obvious insult to Paul.
  
  If you don't want someone to call you an idiot, Don't be an idiot. If you don't want a discussion, Don't say "If you don't like it, move on elsewhere" then don't reply. If you do, Then don't tell me to move on and continue with this discussion.
  
  Anything else?

  • Report
  

  by Awesome on August 8th, 2011

• So,just remind me again,who called who an idiot first ? Me thinks it was yourself to someone who has the right to an opinion that differs from your own.You can't use expressive language in the first place and think you get away with it,either behind the sanctity and safety of a computer screen or any place else.I'm not angry by any stretch,all I did was respond to your own misguided retort....ever heard the childish saying it takes one to know one ? And is ceases to be a discussion when name calling...that's when it becomes an argument.Fully prepared to have a discussion regarding the merits of Lennon & McCartney,but I refuse to be called an idiot for having a differing opinion from your own.
  
  As regards 'Anything else ?' -- Who's being arrogant now ?
  
  As regards your last appraisal of the said musicians Starkey & Harrison,Christ Almighty everyone knows Ringo Starr was a piss poor drummer,he only got in the band 'cos Lennon wanted him.Even George Martin fucked him off from the recording of Love Me Do because he'd already paid for a session musician to drum on the record.Didn't McCartney drum on some songs on The White Album ? As for George Harrison,even Lennon admitted he was dissapionted with his input as he just sat back and let himself and McCartney write the tunes.Harrison learnt his craft by just watching.Have a watch of the documentary Let It Be,they were falling apart during those recording sessions.
  
  :)

  • Report
  

  by kidder1 on August 8th, 2011

• Keepin_it_Classy says it all in that comment....see ya ROFPMSL.

  • Report
  

  by kidder1 on August 9th, 2011

• In the same way you attempted to keep it classy in your previous posts? ROFPMSL!

  • Report
  

  by Awesome on August 9th, 2011

• Keepin_it_Classy is a username here who commented on your question you posted originally....

  • Report
  

  by kidder1 on August 9th, 2011

• I wouldn't use him as a reference, Especially since he fails to refer to ANYTHING and simply said
  
  "Lennon was better, better songs, less obnoxious personality."
  
  First of all, I was curious why he'd bring up peronalities. I thought when I asked which was better I was implying musically. Since no one actually knew them personally. Because I wouldn't bring up personality traits since John use to hit his ex-wife Cynthia and repeatedly cheated on her and abandoned his own son Julian.
  
  And he never said why Lennon's songs were better.
  
  So please, If you want to continue this discussion. Then stop ignoring my points and we'll have a proper discussion. If you're going to continue being an idiot, Oh wait you get offended when people call you an idiot. If you're going to continue not properly countering my points and continue to insult Ringo who devoted his drumming to the tune rather then pull a bonham. Then we'll end the debate now and you shouldn't bother replying to this, If you're going to properly have a discussion with me then we'll continue.

  • Report
  

  by Awesome on August 9th, 2011

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments

Comments