by EvangelineOFire on November 13th, 2009

EvangelineOFire

Question

Help answer this question below.

Do you think that American football players, so used to wearing all their protective gear, could handle Rugby or Aussie Rules football?

  • Like
  • Report

Answers. Showing one answer.

  • by jackpipe30 on November 13th, 2009

    jackpipe30

    Some of the guys are massive, but being that big doesn't mean that they are out of shape. They have to take fitness tests each year and they run to keep up cardio. That said, the offensive linemen would have a hard time with the pace of rugby, but the 'skill' players would not. The skill set needed for rugby seems to be a hybrid between football and soccer, so it would be an easy transition as far as fitness levels go, but difficult as far as strategy goes. I'd take a bunch of linebackers, defensive ends, corners, safeties, tight ends, tailbacks, and fullbacks as a rugby team any day, and maybe even some defensive linemen. Quarterbacks, most wide receivers, and offensive linemen aren't really built for that game, the o-linemen are too big, not necessarily out of shape, but just massive and quarterbacks and wide receivers aren't generally large enough and most would be too tall, because from what I've seen a shorter strong build with quickness and speed are desired (please correct me if I'm wrong).

    Comments
    • Australian Rules ruckmen are generally tall and rangy - 6 foot 4 is too short. However, ruckmen jump VERY high (and crash into each other) every few minutes. I doubt the Yanks would have the leap. And have you ever seen an Aussie Rules marking contest? Riding on opponents' or team mates' shoulders? They don't GET that high in NFL.

      Slartibartfast

      by Slartibartfast on March 10th, 2011

    • I don't understand the term "ruckman". I assume it is one who goes down the field and catches the ball since they are tall and lanky. I seriously doubt that the verticle leaping ability would be lacking in our wide receivers. In the NFL, you can't use a team mate as a base for jumping or be carried in any way. Ha ha, I know some players in the NFL that get pretty HIGH, they make the news when they get busted.

      jackpipe30

      by jackpipe30 on March 10th, 2011

    • Ruckmen are the blokes that contest the bounces - a bit like a jump ball in basketball, except for the hard body contact. Actually, basketballers would probably be better at Australian Rules than American footballers, if they could stand the hits.

      Slartibartfast

      by Slartibartfast on March 10th, 2011

    • Oh, and you can't use a team mate as a base for jumping in Aus rules, either - they jump onto their mates (or opponents) shoulders, while said mate or opponent is standing upright, from the ground. Ruckmen aren't the main culprits for that caper, it's the half-forwards and full-forwards who do it.

      Slartibartfast

      by Slartibartfast on March 11th, 2011

    • I'm going to have to catch a game sometime and watch the subtle nuances of the game....may be able to do that with the crybabies in the NFL sitting out the season wanting more money. I've not seen it much since I was stationed in Korea (our English speaking cable provider was out of Australia, so we got a lot of soccer, Aussie Rules Football, and the show "Who Dares Wins".

      jackpipe30

      by jackpipe30 on March 12th, 2011

    • Geez, that was a while ago - I assume you mean the program that was hosted by cricket legend Mike Whitney?

      Slartibartfast

      by Slartibartfast on March 14th, 2011

    • I don't remember who the host was, but it was back in 2000. People would get small sums of money for doing crazy dangerous crap like diving a shipwreck on their first time SCUBA diving or milking a Funnel Web Spider.

      jackpipe30

      by jackpipe30 on March 25th, 2011

    • As a general rule I like spiders but those buggers scare me. I grew up in the Blue Mountains west of Sydney - you didn't dare go outside barefoot.

      Slartibartfast

      by Slartibartfast on March 25th, 2011

Want to attach an image to your answer? Click here.

Did this answer your question? If not, then ask a new question or create a poll.

You're reading Do you think that American football players, so used to wearing all their protective gear, could handle Rugby or Aussie Rules football?

Follow us on Facebook!

Related Ads